Granular Sludge: A Promising Innovation for More Efficient Settling


  • Wendell Khunjar PhD, PE, Mark Strahota PE, Paul Pitt PhD, PE, Ron Latimer PE - Hazen and Sawyer|
  • Kevin Gilmore PhD - Bucknell University

Aerobic granular sludge represents an emerging approach for intensifying biological treatment at WRRFs in order to do more with less. Early adopters are already seeing substantial benefits over an activated sludge process.

The development of granules for use in WRRFs for facilitating intensified organic and nutrient removal is being studied.

Hazen is working with Gregg Township Municipal Authority (GTMA) on a strategy to intensify nutrient removal capability. The current work is focused on promoting enrichment of biological phosphorus removal organisms as a means for enhancing settling properties and potentially stimulating granule formation.

The roots of this research began in the late 19th century and continue to evolve through the present day.

As the water industry increasingly transitions to a resource recovery paradigm, the intensification of biological processes within existing infrastructure often means doing more with less. Here’s a closer look at one such promising technology alternative that could be coming soon to a water resource reclamation facility (WRRF) near you.

The water resource reclamation industry is rapidly transitioning towards embracing the resource recovery paradigm, whereby resources within wastewater and infrastructure at water resource reclamation facilities (WRRFs) are beneficially exploited for constructive use. Biological treatment for carbon and nutrient control is expected to remain a core process for WRRFs of the future. Advancing biological technologies that allow for unlocking treatment capacity, while also minimizing capital and operating costs is therefore critical.

Aerobic granular sludge (AGS) represents a technology that allows for biological treatment intensification, thereby reducing footprint requirements, energy and operating costs as compared to traditional activated sludge technologies. In AGS, biomass are enriched into dense aggregates, where stratification of biomass allows for multiple processes to occur within the granule.

To date, full-scale application of AGS has been limited to the approach utilized by one technology provider (NEREDA™). Much research is underway to develop alternative granulation strategies that can be used to retrofit AGS into existing WRRFs. In this paper/presentation, we will report findings from an ongoing effort to stimulate granulation using metabolic selectors at the Gregg Township Municipal Authority WRRF (GTWRRF). This work is being performed in an attempt to intensify treatment and improve nutrient removal reliability.

Facility Description
The GTWRRF is designed to treat 1.26 mgd using a sequential batch reactor configuration. The facility does not practice anaerobic digestion and has historically achieved effluent TN and TP less than 5 mg/L and 3 mg/L respectively. In the future, the GTWRRF will need to meet effluent TP concentrations below 0.8 mg/L. Additionally, landfill leachate will be imported to the facility in 2017. In an attempt to maximize the existing facility and minimize capital upgrades, AGS was identified as an option that would potentially allow the GTWRRF to achieve the future treatment limits even with leachate addition.

The team hypothesized that enhancing biological phosphorus removal (Bio-P) through exploitation of metabolic selectors would also facilitate improvements to sludge settling characteristics and potentially stimulate granulation. A multi-pronged approach was utilized to identify potential improvements including sampling, batch testing, process modeling and full-scale testing

Results and Discussion
Full-scale testing of zero capital modifications is currently underway at the GTWRRF. Interim findings indicate:
• Settling velocity has increased by 40% while sludge volume indices have decreased by 20%.
• During this period, effluent soluble phosphorous concentrations have also decreased by 50% to 1.6 mg/L.
• This improvement in performance has also coincided with enrichment of Bio-P organisms within the biomass. Denitrifying phosphorus accumulating organism activity was detected.
• Intrinsic settling velocity testing also indicate a shift toward larger and denser particles in the mixed liquor at the GTWRRF.

For more information, please contact the author at

Hear about new publications with our email newsletter

We will never share your details with anyone else.


Newsletter Newsletter

Horizons Fall 2017 (pdf)

Horizons showcases significant water, wastewater, reuse, and stormwater projects and innovations that help our clients to achieve their goals, and can help you achieve yours. Articles are written by top engineers and process group leaders, demonstrating and explaining the beneficial application of a variety of technologies and tools.

View previous issues »